Serving Huntington, IN | 260-356-4400

Mettler Agency Inc - Logo Facebook
internal Insurance

Safeco Insurance

Claim: 800-279-7221

Billing: 800-667-0608


Indiana Farmers

Claim: 800-601-7911

Billing: 888-809-3434

Bristol West

Claim: 800-274-7865

Billing: 888-888-0070

About Mettler Agency Inc

Contact us today or pay your bill through our partners.

Get insured with a locally owned and operated business. Call Mettler Agency Inc!


Society Insurance Safeco Insurance Indiana Farmers Travelers Auto-Owners Insurance Progressive Bristol West Insurance Group Dairyland Auto Insurance

Society Insurance

Claim: 888-576-2438 ext. 5514

Billing: 888-576-2438 ext. 5522

Liberty Mutual

Claim: 800-279-7221

Billing: 800-667-0608


Claim: 800-252-4633

Billing: 800-842-5075

Auto Owners

Claim: 800-523-5846

Billing: 800-346-0346


Claim: 877-776-2436

Billing: 877-776-2436

Liberty Mutual Insurance


Claim: 800-527-3907

Billing: 800-532-4221

West Bend Foremost